5 delicious and healthy alternatives to peanut butter

They’re packed with nutrients, increasingly available in stores—and tasty, too.

closeup of almond butter in jar

Updated on November 18, 2024.

Maybe you don’t like peanut butter. Or maybe you’re allergic to peanuts—one of the most common food allergens in the United States. Or maybe you just want to try something different with your sandwich, banana, or oatmeal. 

That’s where nut butters come in. Increasingly available in U.S. supermarkets, nut butters come in a variety of flavors, including almond, cashew, and walnut. They also contain several important nutrients, including protein, heart-healthy fats, fiber, magnesium, zinc, iron, and vitamin E. In fact, eating nut butter regularly is linked to lower chances of developing heart disease or type 2 diabetes.

If you’re interested in trying these tasty alternatives to peanut butter, it's wise to follow a few shopping guidelines:

  • The fats found in nut butters are mostly unsaturated, which are good for your heart health. But they do contain some saturated fat and tend to be calorie dense. So, limit yourself to 1 or 2 tablespoons daily, or less if you eat any other nuts during the day. 
  • Look for products with a short ingredient list and little-to-no added sugar, salt, or hydrogenated vegetable oils.
  • Once you open a jar of nut butter, store the rest in the fridge. It can go rancid over time.

With those tips in mind, here are nut butters you may want to try.

Almond butter

Since it has a similar texture, almond butter is perhaps the most popular alternative to peanut butter. And while you can easily buy a jar in a store, it’s also—like many nut butters—simple to make at home. Simply take 1 pound of raw almonds and run it through a food processor on low speed until it forms a smooth paste. This may take several minutes, but patience will pay off eventually.

Among its many uses, almond butter can be included in baked goods, made into a dip for fruits and vegetables, or added to smoothies.

Cashew butter

Creamy and mild, cashew butter can be used as a dairy substitute in some soup, sauce, and curry recipes (one reason why it’s popular among vegans). It tends to be a little lighter in protein than other nut butters. 

Macadamia nut butter

Like cashew butter, macadamia nut butter can be used in some cases as an alternative to dairy products—especially butter and margarine. Give broiled tilapia or flounder a surprisingly flavorful twist, for example, by brushing it with a little melted macadamia butter. Smoothies and spreads are other tasty applications.

The main drawbacks of macadamia butter tend to be availability and cost. Comparatively speaking, macadamia nuts are often harder to find and more expensive than other nuts. 

Pecan butter

While you can drizzle it on top of a sundae, don’t confuse pecan butter with butter pecan, a popular ice cream flavor combining the flavors of pecan, butter, and vanilla. If you’re making your own, try toasting the nuts beforehand and adding a little cinnamon towards the end of blending. Then, use it as you would any other nut butter.

Walnut butter

While every nut has advantages, walnuts are a special case. They’re one of the best dietary sources of alpha-linolenic acid (AHA), a healthy fat that can help reduce inflammation and lower the risk of heart disease. Other good sources include chia seeds, flaxseeds, canola oil, and soybean oil.

Walnut butter does tend to be a tad bitter. To counter this, add a little honey or warm spice to the butter itself. Or, pair it with something sweet, like apricot jam on a whole-grain bagel. 

Article sources open article sources

USDA Food Safety & Inspection Service. Food Allergies: The “Big 9.” Updated March 21, 2024.
American Heart Association. Nut butters are a healthy way to spread nutrients. August 14, 2020.
Cedars-Sinai. Nut Butters: Which One Is Healthiest? January 17, 2020.
Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. The Nutrition Source: Almonds. Accessed November 18, 2024.
Australian Macadamias. So What Exactly Is Macadamia Nut Butter? Accessed November 18, 2024.
NIH: Office of Dietary Supplements. Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals. February 15, 2023.

More On

What do I need to know about over-the-counter laxatives?

video

What do I need to know about over-the-counter laxatives?
Laxatives to treat constipation can be dangerous if you don’t follow the directions exactly. Robin Miller, MD, shares natural ways to get things movin...
4 must-know facts about listeria

article

4 must-know facts about listeria
Learn more about listeria contamination in food—and what you can do to protect yourself.
10 smart snacks under 200 calories

slideshow

10 smart snacks under 200 calories
Whether you’re craving sweet or salty, these healthy snacks are the perfect choice.
Why should I wash produce before I eat it?

video

Why should I wash produce before I eat it?
Every year, 30,000 people in the U.S. die of food poisoning, and not always from eating meat. Joy Dubost, PhD, gives her tips for avoiding fruit and v...
What are healthy gluten-free foods?

video

What are healthy gluten-free foods?
Healthy gluten-free foods are any real, whole foods that aren't made from the grains that contain gluten, like wheat. Functional medicine expert Mark ...