Search

See All Plastic Surgeons in New York, NY
Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD
Cosmetic, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery*
Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD
3.9 (15 Ratings)

Offers telehealth

Share
icon-circle-check
Link Copied!
Profile link copied to clipboard!
Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD is a Plastic Surgeon in New York, NY.
Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD
3.9 (15 Ratings)
Share
icon-circle-check
Link Copied!
Profile link copied to clipboard!

Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD

Cosmetic, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery*
New York, NY
Accepting new patients
26 years of experience

Offers telehealth

Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD is a Plastic Surgeon in New York, NY.

About

Dr. McCarthy graduated from McMaster University. Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD is a Plastic Surgeon in New York, NY and has 26 years experience. Dr. McCarthy currently practices at Practice and are affiliated with Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. Dr. McCarthy has experience treating conditions like Capsular Contracture of Breast Implant among other conditions at varying frequencies. At present, Dr. McCarthy received an average rating of 3.9/5 from patients and has been reviewed 15 times. Dr. McCarthy's office accepts new patients and telehealth appointments. Dr. McCarthy accepts multiple insurance plans.

Offers Telehealth

This provider offers telehealth appointments. Call the office to schedule.

Trustworthy

Patients said this doctor is trustworthy.

Friendly Staff

Patients said the staff was friendly.

Easy Scheduling

Patients said scheduling was easy.

Compare with other Plastic Surgeons

Compare Dr. McCarthy with our nearby Plastic Surgeons at Mount Sinai Hospital
These providers are on the medical staff of Mount Sinai Hospital
These providers are on the medical staff of Mount Sinai Hospital.
Advertisement

Experience Check

Enter a condition or procedure
Capsular Contracture of Breast Implant
Breast Lift Surgery
Breast Reconstruction
Capsular Contracture of Breast Implant
Capsular Contracture of Breast Implant
Breast Lift Surgery
Breast Reconstruction
Gynecomastia
Skin Cancer
Soft Tissue Sarcoma of Head, Face, and Neck
Adjacent Tissue Transfer
Breast Reduction
Excision of Benign Skin Lesion
Excision of Skin Lesion
Nipple Reconstruction
Skin and Tissue Reduction
Skin Grafts
Wound Repair
Bedsores
  • View other providers who treat Bedsores
Birthmark
Breast Ptosis
Congenital Anomalies of Breast
Deformities of Auricle or Pinna
Dentofacial Anomalies
Hidradenitis
Lip Cancer
Localized Fat Deposits
Moles (Benign Skin Lesions)
Spider Veins
Abdominoplasty
Breast Augmentation
Dermal Filler
Destruction of Benign Skin Lesion
Destruction of Malignant Skin Lesion
Dressing and Debridement of Wound or Infection
Excision of Skin Cancer
Eyelid Surgery
Facial Reconstruction
Labiaplasty
Liposuction
Mohs Defect Reconstruction Surgery
Reconstructive Eyelid Surgery
Repair of Brow Ptosis and Blepharoptosis
Tattooing

Insurance Accepted

* Please verify this information when scheduling an appointment.
  • Curative PPO
    Curative EPO
    Curative PPO Plus
  • AWH NJ Choice MultiTier POS II
    Select
    Elect Choice (Open Access) EPO
    Premier Care Network Plus - Innovation Health
    Managed Choice (Open Access) POS
    AWH NJ Choice MultiTier - Standard Savings POS II
    Choice Plus POS II
  • First Health (Coventry Health Care) PPO
  • Choice Plus POS
    Nexus Open Access
    Navigate POS
    Options PPO
    Navigate HMO
  • Flex Connecticut EPO
  • Freedom
  • MVP Health Plan EPO
  • High Performance Network - Tiered HPN
    Blue Card High Performance Network HPN
    Blue Card PPO
  • myBlue Access EPO
    Blue High Performance Network
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield of Western New York PPO
  • Blue Priority NY EPO
    Connection Employer Sponsored
    Blue Acess Employer Sponsored
    Connection Blue High Performance Network
    Empire Hospital
    Empire Hospital/Medical (Trad)
    National Blue High Performance Network
    Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield PPO
  • Open Access Plus
    Cigna PPO
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
  • HIP Prime HMO
    GHI CBP
  • BluePPO HSA PPO

Locations

  1. 1 Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center
    1275 York Ave, New York, NY 10065

Patient Satisfaction

Likelihood to recommend Dr. McCarthy
3.9
Based on 15 Reviews
5 Stars (11)
4 Stars (0)
3 Stars (0)
2 Stars (0)
1 Star (4)

Leave a review

How likely are you to recommend Dr. McCarthy?

(Select your rating)
Patient Reviews
Jun 23, 2025
Dr. Colleen McCarthy, with her extensive experience and dedication, will always provide you with the correct answer to improve your situation. I highly recommend McCarthy very professional.I underwent surgery for breast lift and reduction after completing my cancer treatment.Thank you, MD Colleen McCarthy Eres la mejor
— Jun 23, 2025
See more reviews on Healthgrades
Photo: Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD
How would you rate your experience with Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD?
  • Likelihood of recommending Dr. McCarthy to family and friends

Dr. McCarthy's Office & Staff

  • Ease of scheduling urgent appointments
  • Office environment, cleanliness, comfort, etc.
  • Staff friendliness and courteousness
  • Total wait time (waiting & exam rooms)

Experience with Dr. McCarthy

  • Level of trust in provider's decisions
  • How well provider explains medical condition(s)
  • How well provider listens and answers questions
  • Hpends appropriate amount of time with patients

Tell Us About Yourself

  • Your gender:
  • Your age group:
  • Number of office visits you've had in the last 2 years:

Finish Here

  • How would you like to confirm your survey information?
    Standard text messaging and data rates may apply.
Thank you for sharing your feedback about Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD.
Claim Your Profile
Are you Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD?
Respond to reviews, add information, and reach more patients. Claiming is free and only takes a minute.

Claim my profile
Telehealth Options
This provider has not specified a telehealth appointment method. Would you still like to make an appointment with Dr. McCarthy?
Call now to make an appointment
(212) 639-7671

About Me

Specialties*
Cosmetic, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery
Specialties*
  • *Sharecare does not verify qualifications for medical specialties. Please verify your provider's specialty and qualifications directly with your provider and applicable medical board.
Education

Education

Medical Education
  • McMaster University
    1999
Medical Education
Common Questions and Answers
Responses are sourced directly from patients.
Does Dr. McCarthy communicate via email?
3 users said yes.
Yes
(3)
No
(2)
Does Dr. McCarthy offer telehealth services or virtual visits?
3 users said yes.
Yes
(3)
No
(1)
Does Dr. McCarthy offer an online patient portal?
4 users said yes.
Yes
(4)
No
(0)
Does Dr. McCarthy have free onsite parking?
4 users said yes.
Yes
(4)
No
(1)
Does Dr. McCarthy offer weekend visits?
2 users said yes.
Yes
(2)
No
(3)
Does Dr. McCarthy offer evening visits?
2 users said yes.
Yes
(2)
No
(3)
Does Dr. McCarthy specialize in working with children or adolescents?
No responses yet.
Yes
(0)
No
(0)
Does Dr. McCarthy specialize in working with seniors?
No responses yet.
Yes
(0)
No
(0)
Does Dr. McCarthy specialize in couples therapy?
No responses yet.
Yes
(0)
No
(0)
Does Dr. McCarthy specialize in working with LGBTQ+ community?
No responses yet.
Yes
(0)
No
(0)
Does Dr. McCarthy accept insurance?
No responses yet.
Yes
(0)
No
(0)

Frequently Asked Questions

Find contact information here to make an appointment.

A list of accepted insurance providers is available on the Sharecare insurance check. It is always a good idea to verify your insurance when making an appointment.

New patients are generally accepted by Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD. To arrange an appointment, call the number on Dr. McCarthy's profile.

Dr. McCarthy frequently treats the following conditions: Capsular Contracture of Breast Implant. See more on Sharecare.

Dr. Colleen McCarthy, MD is affiliated with Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center.

Hospital Affiliations

  • Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center

    1275 York Ave, New York, NY